Homeschooling versus Traditional Schooling

School versus Homeschooling Some people believe that teaching children at home is best for a child's development while others think that it is important for children to go to school. Discuss the advantages of both methods and give your own opinion.

Annotated response

10 correction notes

Showing 10 correction notes.

Many people are in debate about whether children should be home-schooled or traditionally-schooled, and which of the two methods would be better for the child's development. While studying privately means the child will be getting a more focused and tailored education, traditional schools provide children with social and physical advantages that home-schooling does not. In this essay, I will discuss the benefits of both preferences and explain why I believe that children should be made to go into school rather than being restricted to text-book education. Parents who choose to get private tutors for their children tend to believe that they will be getting a better education and will be smarter than publicly educated children. This is because the ratio means that the child is getting all of the teacher's attention, in comparison with public school where the teacher has to divide his/her attention between twenty or thirty different children. For instance, if a tutor that their pupil is struggling with algebra, it would be much easier to identify and address it. Whereas, in public schools the teacher might not know unless it is raised by the student or parent. Even then, it would be difficult to find the time and energy to help the individual student. In this aspect home-schooling might be more advantageous than public schooling. Nevertheless, the other components of child education and development should still be explored. Being taught with other children has numerous advantages that are often overlooked by supporters of home-schooling. One very obvious benefit is social interaction and its importance in dealing with strangers, learning social etiquette, building relationships and much more. Children who are given the opportunity to interact with other children and be far more socially advanced than those who are their homes. Furthermore, children who are publicly educated are able to explore and develop more interests than their privately tutored peers. For example, most will play team games with their class at some point during their school years; through this they might find a new interest or hobby, they will be able to learn new skills, interact and experience competition but most importantly enjoy themselves. Through these interactions they also create relationships that extend beyond the school grounds. These are opportunities that can rarely be described for homeschooled children. The social components and fully experiencing childhood is fundamental to healthy development and must not be overlooked when choosing from the two options. In my opinion, the social advantages gained from public school surpass the academic advantages of home-schooling. This is because while the child will learn better if his/her classes are tailored to his or her need, they may never encounter the social experiences from which they can extract skills or enjoy the atmosphere of being with children. The aim of school is to prepare children for adult life and equip them with the skills they may need at that time, of whether they progress into academic disciplines or not. Education gaps can be corrected by parents at home or after school tutoring where is no substitute for the social benefits of school. In , parents choose which style of teaching best fits their expectations for their children. While some go with home tutoring, others go with traditional schooling; they both come with varying advantages. This essay discussed the main advantage of traditional schooling versus homeschooling in relation to the child’s development. It highlighted the academic benefits of private learning, as well as the social and personal gains of public school education, and explained why I think that traditional methods of schooling are far more advantageous than homeschooling.

Overall assessment

Why this response received Band 7.0

The strongest aspect is the well-developed, clearly structured argument that presents both advantages and reaches a firm, well-supported personal opinion. The main limitation is a sprinkling of language slips, including spelling, word choice, and punctuation errors, that occasionally disrupt an otherwise fluent response.

IELTS criteria

How each score was decided

Task Response

7.0

The response addresses all parts of the task, presents a clear position throughout, and develops main ideas with relevant explanation and examples.

Coherence and Cohesion

7.0

Ideas progress logically across well-organised paragraphs with effective cohesive devices, though a few transitions and the conclusion feel slightly mechanical.

Lexical Resource

7.0

Vocabulary is sufficiently flexible and mostly precise, with some less natural choices such as 'secluded to their homes' and 'irregardless'.

Grammatical Range and Accuracy

7.0

A good range of complex sentence structures is used with generally strong control, despite occasional errors like 'a tutor see's' and the incomplete phrase 'In ,'.