Sample response & feedback

Free Public Libraries vs Internet Access

Question

Some people think that the government should provide free public libraries in every town, while others think that this is a waste of money because people can access information on the internet. Discuss both viewpoints and give your own opinion.

Annotated response

10 correction notes

Showing 10 correction notes.

Some people argue that governments should provide free public libraries in every town, whereas others believe such spending is unnecessary because information is widely available online. Although digital access has transformed how people obtain knowledge, this essay maintains that public libraries remain a worthwhile investment because they promote educational equality and deliver wider social benefits. allocating public funds to physical libraries is inefficient in the digital age. Online databases, e-books, and educational platforms allow users to access large volumes of information quickly and at minimal cost. For instance, students can download academic materials instantly without travelling to a library, while professionals can update their skills through online courses. This suggests that maintaining library buildings and printed resources may appear redundant. Nevertheless, this view assumes that all citizens have equal access to technology and sufficient digital literacy, which is not always the case, particularly among low-income or rural populations. publicly funded libraries continue to play a crucial role in supporting inclusive education and community development. Libraries provide free access to reliable resources, quiet study spaces, and , enabling disadvantaged learners to participate more fully in education. Moreover, many libraries function as community centres that host literacy programmes, cultural events, and training workshops, fostering social interaction and lifelong learning. These functions extend well beyond information retrieval and cannot be fully replaced by digital platforms. In conclusion, although online resources reduce reliance on traditional libraries, continued government investment remains justified. Public libraries promote equal access to knowledge and strengthen community engagement, making them a valuable long-term public asset.

Overall assessment

Why this response received Band 7.5

The response discusses both viewpoints and consistently supports public libraries. Its argument progresses clearly from online convenience to unequal access and wider community benefits, using varied vocabulary and accurate complex sentences. Further development could clarify the case for provision in every town, explain how particular library services produce the claimed benefits, and qualify broad assumptions about internet access and the limits of digital platforms.

IELTS criteria

How each score was decided

TR Task Response

8.0

Both viewpoints are addressed directly, a clear position is maintained throughout, and main ideas are well developed with relevant examples, with only occasional slight genericness in support.

CC Coherence and Cohesion

8.0

Paragraphing is logical and cohesive devices are used skilfully and unobtrusively, giving clear progression throughout the argument.

LR Lexical Resource

7.0

Vocabulary is varied, natural and appropriate to the topic, including educational equality, digital literacy and community engagement. Broad expressions such as professional guidance could identify the service more precisely.

GRA Grammatical Range and Accuracy

7.5

Complex concession, relative and participial structures are used accurately and flexibly throughout. No clear grammatical error is evident in the supplied response.